News & Views

Is Surgery Becoming a Spectator Sport? - Bombay Times, Downtown

Published on 10th Sept. 2004 in Bombay Times Downtown, Priya Sugathan

 

‘Come and watch a live surgery being performed with the latest technology’ reads the latest surge of invites from the medical world. Are we going the western way where reality shows are making a spectator sport out of surgeries?

“Live surgery is not new to India. A surgery being performed is relayed to the target audience, which comprises of medical students, general practitioners, media,” informs Dr. Ameet Pispate, orthopaedic surgeon who is credited to be the First Asian to perform the hip resurfacing technique. “The purpose is to create an awareness of new surgery techniques. It goes against medical rules to relay it to lay people.” He does not include the recorded version of the surgery, which is given to the relatives of the patient. These are now considered routine with the Shroff Eye Hospital. “Relatives watch the surgery taking place on the monitor providing transparency,” Says Dr. Anand Shroff, who conducted live surgery with the latest LASIK laser vision correction, with the media present in large groups.

Medics, at large, deny that there is any self-promotion involved in having live surgeries. “It is not self-promotion, but rather a promotion of new techniques to make people aware of it,” says Dr Sanjay Borude, anti-obesity surgeon. “One can even train even train students from other countries through live transmission of the surgery.” There, however, is a thin line between educating about a technique and promoting. “The medical world does not allow for self-promotion, at least not in allopathy,” informs Dr. Pispate who’s set to conduct a live surgery of hip resurfacing this weekend at a symposium in the city. It’ll be attended by 250 orthopaedic surgeons.

It would be interesting for the Indian medical community to note that surgeries are now being tapped as a ‘reality show’ potential abroad. Cosmetic Surgery Live on channel Five in UK has a clinic recording cosmetic surgeries live for two weeks, and the patients include some well-known local celebrities. The programme created a furore with its announcement and was slammed by many, including television viewers and professional of the medic world as something “private that should not be shown on national network and will probably start off an onslaught of copy cats.”

Dr. Shroff is aware of a similar thing happening in America and sees nothing wrong in it. “People will be less intimidated and more informed about surgeries,” he says. Dr. Pispate demurs, “A hip resurfacing or an angioplasty will require to show a part of body that I don’t think any of our patients would like to show. It’s not fair. Honestly, I don’t see surgery turning out to be a part of the reality series in India.”

With Indians quick on the uptake at the copying the West, how long will it be before they seek out the ‘lovable heart’ for dissection thrills?

 
 
Is Surgery Becoming a Spectator Sport? - Bombay Times, Downtown
| Home Page | About Us | Why LASIK | Principles | Consultation | Procedure | LASIK Surgery | Instructions | Recovery | Wave Front | Contraindications | Retreatment |
| Our Centre | Doctor | Our Laser | Commitment | Safety | FDA Comparison | Epi-LASIK | LASIK Eye Surgery | C3R + Topo guided PRK | Testimonials | LASIK India
| News & Views | FAQ's - LASIK | FAQ's - Keratoconus | Directions | Contact Us

                                         Copyright © 2005 - 2006 Neisa Laser Centre